The router should have DHCP enabled. Without it only 1 PC at a time will connect.
Turn off the wirless security.
Connect the MAC and 1 lappy to the router via RJ45 network cables.
Turn everything off.
Turn on the modem, wait for it to stabilise.
Turn on the router and wait for it to stabilise.
Turn on the MAC.
Turn on the wired lappy.
Turn on the wireless lappy and search for your wireless router.
Once a wireless connection is established, go back to the router settings and setup wirless security. You will have to re establish a connection with the wireless lappy and enter the security key.
Ignore the PPPOE settings, they are not required.
Charge them £20.00, call it a day and let us know how you got on.