Cable Forum

Cable Forum (https://www.cableforum.uk/board/index.php)
-   General IT Discussion (https://www.cableforum.uk/board/forumdisplay.php?f=19)
-   -   Investigatory powers act who will access my data? (https://www.cableforum.uk/board/showthread.php?t=33704032)

techguyone 27-11-2016 12:21

Investigatory powers act who will access my data?
 
I thought this might make a change from brexit, migrants, trump, thatcher etc etc.

It looks like it's finally happened, Labour tried it, the coalition sorta tried it, and now the Conservatives have finally managed it.

Investigatory Powers Act

Shortly we'll be about to have the most invasive Internet surveillance in the world launched upon us. Not to mention the security risk posed by ISP storing all that data, remember the Talk Talk data breach?
The Ashley Madison data breach?
How happy are you to have the ISP's store your data for 12 months so that the following people can access it - all without a warrant.

Quote:

Metropolitan police force
City of London police force
Police forces maintained under section 2 of the Police Act 1996
Police Service of Scotland
Police Service of Northern Ireland
British Transport Police
Ministry of Defence Police
Royal Navy Police
Royal Military Police
Royal Air Force Police
Security Service
Secret Intelligence Service
GCHQ
Ministry of Defence
Department of Health
Home Office
Ministry of Justice
National Crime Agency
HM Revenue & Customs
Department for Transport
Department for Work and Pensions
NHS trusts and foundation trusts in England that provide ambulance services
Common Services Agency for the Scottish Health Service
Competition and Markets Authority
Criminal Cases Review Commission
Department for Communities in Northern Ireland
Department for the Economy in Northern Ireland
Department of Justice in Northern Ireland
Financial Conduct Authority
Fire and rescue authorities under the Fire and Rescue Services Act 2004
Food Standards Agency
Food Standards Scotland
Gambling Commission
Gangmasters and Labour Abuse Authority
Health and Safety Executive
Independent Police Complaints Commissioner
Information Commissioner
NHS Business Services Authority
Northern Ireland Ambulance Service Health and Social Care Trust
Northern Ireland Fire and Rescue Service Board
Northern Ireland Health and Social Care Regional Business Services Organisation
Office of Communications
Office of the Police Ombudsman for Northern Ireland
Police Investigations and Review Commissioner
Scottish Ambulance Service Board
Scottish Criminal Cases Review Commission
Serious Fraud Office
Welsh Ambulance Services National Health Service Trust
Quite big isn't it.

Yes I know, 'nothing to hide nothing to fear' yada yada

Not so funny though when some hacktivist hacks your ISP and there's all that yummy data just sat there.

--------

There are thnigs people can do if they feel that perhaps a smidgen of privacy might be rather nice.

This article is quite useful.

https://www.theguardian.com/technol....nment-snoopers

and this showing the torrentfreak vpn review 2016

https://torrentfreak.com/vpn-anonymous-review-160220/

It would be nice to know other members feelings on this, and perhaps any VPNs etc they may recommend.

Remember - whilst the ISP's only keep your data for 12 months, Government agencies who scrape that data can potentially keep it forever.

In that case, whilst perhaps this government may well be ok in that regard, what about the next one, or the one after?
We all saw what happened when Councils got access to people via the RIPA act, the potential for misuse is massive.
Food for thought.

arcimedes 27-11-2016 13:12

Re: Investigatory powers act who will access my data?
 
As I understand it what is stored is sites you visited and not any data. If they stored any data you transferred they would run out of space very quickly.

heero_yuy 27-11-2016 13:36

Re: Investigatory powers act who will access my data?
 
I think this will have a number of consequences:

Many people will seriously restrict their use of cloud resources. I would never put any critical data in a cloud space.

Those involved in clandestine activities will use VPNs and encrypted peer-to-peer messaging apps like bleep and the authorities will have no data to pursue. This has the exact opposite effect to that which it is intended. When you know that you'll be snooped on you take precautions

It will be abused by all the authorities in the OP's list.

Damien 28-11-2016 09:04

Re: Investigatory powers act who will access my data?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by heero_yuy (Post 35872110)
I think this will have a number of consequences:

Many people will seriously restrict their use of cloud resources. I would never put any critical data in a cloud space.

Has something changed as far as cloud storage is concerned? I assumed that had the same level of privacy as it always has done, i.e not that much.

I use Dropbox but encrypt the documents myself.

ianch99 28-11-2016 09:18

Re: Investigatory powers act who will access my data?
 
Was this the Bill that Nick Clegg stopped the Tories enacting when he was in power?

techguyone 28-11-2016 10:06

Re: Investigatory powers act who will access my data?
 
Yes or a variant of, both Labour & Con have tried to enact this over the last ten years or so.

heero_yuy 28-11-2016 10:25

Re: Investigatory powers act who will access my data?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Damien (Post 35872223)
Has something changed as far as cloud storage is concerned? I assumed that had the same level of privacy as it always has done, i.e not that much.

I use Dropbox but encrypt the documents myself.

There are many people out there who trust cloud storage for all their personal stuff. You and I know that's not secure but Joe Public is notoriously ignorant of these things. If the bill and the resulting bruhaha highlights the lack of security is that not a bad thing?

tweetiepooh 28-11-2016 10:47

Re: Investigatory powers act who will access my data?
 
Depends what you put into the cloud. If you understand that it's not "secure" but is "safe" then it is a good idea. I don't care if someone does read what I do put on Dropbox, or Amazon photos etc. I am more concerned the data is safe, it's my off site backup.

One trouble is that "secure" can sometimes be more hassle than it's worth. If security gets in the way, people will ignore or find ways to bypass it. Security shouldn't be noticeable unless someone/thing tries to do something they shouldn't.

Paul 28-11-2016 12:46

Re: Investigatory powers act who will access my data?
 
They are basically storing a list of domains you have visited, not the pages, or content.

As to who will access the data - for members of CF I would guess at no one, unless we happen to have some terrorist members we dont know about. These services are extremely busy, and have to justify to senior officers (or equivelent) why they should access this data, they are not going to waste their time doing this unless its actually important. I also think its pointless, since its not really telling them much, plus organised criminal or terror groups will simply bypass such things with VPNs etc.

Damien 28-11-2016 21:46

Re: Investigatory powers act who will access my data?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by heero_yuy (Post 35872232)
There are many people out there who trust cloud storage for all their personal stuff. You and I know that's not secure but Joe Public is notoriously ignorant of these things. If the bill and the resulting bruhaha highlights the lack of security is that not a bad thing?

No I just wondered if there was another part of the bill that I missed. I work on the assumption anything digital is recorded forever and may be available forever.

Hom3r 28-11-2016 21:55

Re: Investigatory powers act who will access my data?
 
I never put private data in the cloud, I store it in my phone's private area which is fingerprint restricted.

TheDaddy 29-11-2016 03:57

Re: Investigatory powers act who will access my data?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by techguyone (Post 35872093)
I thought this might make a change from brexit, migrants, trump, thatcher etc etc.

It looks like it's finally happened, Labour tried it, the coalition sorta tried it, and now the Conservatives have finally managed it.

Investigatory Powers Act

Shortly we'll be about to have the most invasive Internet surveillance in the world launched upon us. Not to mention the security risk posed by ISP storing all that data, remember the Talk Talk data breach?
The Ashley Madison data breach?
How happy are you to have the ISP's store your data for 12 months so that the following people can access it - all without a warrant.



Quite big isn't it.

Yes I know, 'nothing to hide nothing to fear' yada yada

Not so funny though when some hacktivist hacks your ISP and there's all that yummy data just sat there.

--------

There are thnigs people can do if they feel that perhaps a smidgen of privacy might be rather nice.

This article is quite useful.

https://www.theguardian.com/technol....nment-snoopers

and this showing the torrentfreak vpn review 2016

https://torrentfreak.com/vpn-anonymous-review-160220/

It would be nice to know other members feelings on this, and perhaps any VPNs etc they may recommend.

Remember - whilst the ISP's only keep your data for 12 months, Government agencies who scrape that data can potentially keep it forever.

In that case, whilst perhaps this government may well be ok in that regard, what about the next one, or the one after?
We all saw what happened when Councils got access to people via the RIPA act, the potential for misuse is massive.
Food for thought.

I don't think it's good to dismiss privacy with a throw away nothing to hide nothing to fear line

It's like saying free speech isn't important because I have nothing to say imo

RichardCoulter 29-11-2016 07:18

Re: Investigatory powers act who will access my data?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Paul M (Post 35872253)
They are basically storing a list of domains you have visited, not the pages, or content.

As to who will access the data - for members of CF I would guess at no one, unless we happen to have some terrorist members we dont know about. These services are extremely busy, and have to justify to senior officers (or equivelent) why they should access this data, they are not going to waste their time doing this unless its actually important. I also think its pointless, since its not really telling them much, plus organised criminal or terror groups will simply bypass such things with VPNs etc.

True, which is why I think they're using terrorism as an excuse to spy on citizens.

techguyone 29-11-2016 08:13

Re: Investigatory powers act who will access my data?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by TheDaddy (Post 35872389)
I don't think it's good to dismiss privacy with a throw away nothing to hide nothing to fear line

It's like saying free speech isn't important because I have nothing to say imo

I agree totally, my reference was because that's the standard line they trot out with to justify such things.

TheDaddy 29-11-2016 08:44

Re: Investigatory powers act who will access my data?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by techguyone (Post 35872401)
I agree totally, my reference was because that's the standard line they trot out with to justify such things.

Yes I figured that, thought it worth a comment regardless though :)


All times are GMT +1. The time now is 20:05.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.11
Copyright ©2000 - 2024, vBulletin Solutions Inc.